SEOTesting vs Pagereckon Pro: two ways to test an SEO change
SEOTesting is a hosted tool that tests SEO changes on any website with your Search Console data, while Pagereckon Pro measures edits inside WordPress. Both compare clicks before and after a change, yet they suit different teams.
So this page lays out a fair comparison. First the table, then what each tool does best, and finally which one fits your site.
About SEOTesting: A hosted tool that tests SEO changes with your Search Console and Google Analytics data, for any website. Visit their site
| Feature | Pagereckon | SEOTesting |
|---|---|---|
| Price (at the time of writing, October 2026) | Pro from $69 a year for 1 site | From $50 a month for 1 site; 14-day free trial |
| Where it runs | WordPress plugin on your server | Hosted web app, nothing to install on your site |
| Platforms | WordPress only | Any website |
| Data sources | Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, your server log | Search Console, plus Google Analytics when connected |
| Test types | Before and after with a control day | Time-based, split, switch and LLM tests |
| Googlebot re-crawl check | Yes, from the log | Not a listed feature |
| AI crawlers and AI referrals | Yes, in the free plugin | Not a listed feature |
| Where Search Console data lives | On your own server | In the hosted service |
What SEOTesting does well
SEOTesting is built around one question: did the change work? It offers time-based tests for one page or a group, split tests with a control group of similar pages, and switch tests for redirects. It also lists a test type for AI-driven search.
The tool works for any site, because nothing gets installed on the site itself. In addition, it adds reports such as content decay, cannibalization and CTR opportunities, plus a monthly summary and a daily Search Console watch.
At the time of writing, October 2026, plans start at $50 a month for one site and $125 a month for five sites, with a 14-day free trial. Every plan includes unlimited users.
How Pagereckon Pro tests a change
Pagereckon Pro starts from your Search Console data, read on your own server. First, it lists fine-tuning candidates: pages with many impressions and too few clicks. A page in the top 10 gets flagged as a CTR problem, while positions 11 to 30 count as a position problem.
The control-day report
When you edit a page, you mark the change. Then, on the control day (14 days by default), Pro compares the same number of days on each side, up to 28, with the change day left out. It also compares the page with the whole site's Google clicks over the same days.
The verdict is plain: better, worse, no clear change, too little data or too early. A page counts as better or worse only when its clicks moved at least 15% more than the site's and by at least 3 clicks. Our SEO testing page walks through an example.
The log adds context
Because Pagereckon also reads the server log, it knows whether Googlebot crawled the page after your edit. If it did not, the report warns you, so you do not judge an edit Google has not seen yet. The free plugin adds AI crawlers and AI referral traffic too.
SEOTesting or Pagereckon: which fits
Choose by your platform and your team. An agency that tests many kinds of sites, or wants split tests across page groups, will get more from a hosted tool. However, a WordPress owner who wants a simple before and after check per post may prefer a plugin.
Pagereckon has clear limits here. It runs only on WordPress, and it has no split tests or redirect tests. Also, it needs read access to the access log for the crawl check; without it, a PHP request log covers less.
Pick SEOTesting if
- Split tests with a control group of similar pages are part of your process.
- Your sites run on many platforms, not only WordPress.
- Unlimited team seats and content decay or cannibalization reports matter to you.
Pick Pagereckon if
- A WordPress plugin with a yearly price fits your budget better than a monthly service.
- Search Console data should stay on your own server.
- Each report should check whether Googlebot crawled the page after your edit.
- AI crawlers and AI referral visits belong in the same dashboard.
SEOTesting vs Pagereckon: questions
Does SEOTesting need a plugin on my site?
No. It connects to your Google accounts, so nothing runs on the site itself.
Can Pagereckon run split tests?
No. It runs before and after checks per page, compared with the whole site's Google clicks. For split tests, a dedicated tool fits better.
Does Pagereckon Pro need Site Kit?
No. It has its own read-only Google connection, but it can also read Search Console through Site Kit if you already use it.
What does Pagereckon Pro cost?
Personal is $69 a year for one site, Pro is $149 for five and Agency is $299 for 25. See the pricing page for details.