Skip to content
Blog / 7 min read

Which pages to update first: a Search Console method

Most sites have more old posts than time, so the hard part is knowing which pages to update first. Google Search Console already holds the answer: pages that Google shows often but that people rarely click.

This method takes about 30 minutes. You need a Search Console property for your site, a spreadsheet, and the habit of writing down a date.

The Pagereckon team Updated
Which pages to update first at a glance, from Pagereckon

Step 1: open the Performance report

Open Search Console and go to the Performance report. Then set the date filter to the last 28 days. A shorter window gets noisy, while a longer one mixes in old rankings.

Next, tick all four metrics: clicks, impressions, CTR and average position. Switch the table to the Pages tab, so each row shows one URL. Finally, sort by impressions, highest first.

Impressions come first because they show demand. A page with 10,000 impressions and a weak CTR has room to grow. In contrast, a page with 50 impressions can double its CTR and still gain almost nothing.

Step 2: compare CTR with a typical CTR for the position

A CTR of 3% sounds bad. Yet at position 8 it is normal, while at position 2 it is a warning. So you judge each page against a typical CTR for the spot it holds.

Rounded typical organic CTR by position
Average positionTypical CTR
1about 28%
2about 15%
3about 10%
4about 7%
5about 5%
6about 4%
7about 3.3%
8about 2.7%
9about 2.3%
10about 2%
11 to 20about 1%

These are rounded values, the same ones Pagereckon Pro uses. They describe an average result, not a promise. Your niche, the search features on the page and brand searches all move them. Still, they are good enough to rank your own pages against each other.

Step 3: count missed clicks to find which pages to update first

Now turn the gap into one number per page. Add a column to your sheet with this formula:

Missed clicks
missed clicks = impressions x typical CTR for the position - actual clicks

Sort the sheet by missed clicks, highest first. The top rows are the pages to update first, because they waste the most demand. A negative result means the page already beats the typical CTR, so leave it alone for now.

CTR problem or position problem

The position tells you what kind of fix the page needs.

  • Position 1 to 10, a CTR problem. The page ranks, but the result does not win the click. Rewrite the title and the meta description so they match what people search. Google may still rewrite the title link, so check the live result after a few days.
  • Position 11 to 30, a position problem. The page sits on page two or three. A new title will not help much here. Instead, read the queries for that page and answer them better: add the missing section, the direct answer, the table people expect.
  • Below 30. Usually the page does not match the search. Leave it for later.

Ideas for new posts

While you look at queries, switch to the Queries tab. You will often find search terms with impressions where your ranking page only touches the topic. Those terms are ideas for new posts, not for edits. Note them in a separate list.

A worked example: which pages to update first on a small blog

Here is a made-up trail running blog at example.com. Its last 28 days look like this:

Made-up numbers for three pages, last 28 days
PageImpressionsClicksPositionTypical CTRMissed clicks
/best-trail-shoes/12,00024047%12,000 x 7% - 240 = 600
/trail-running-tips/9,00030141%9,000 x 1% - 30 = 60
/hiking-boot-sizing/3,000420215%3,000 x 15% - 420 = 30

The shoe guide wins by far. It holds position 4, so it has a CTR problem. Its title says "Trail Shoes Reviewed", while the top queries ask for the best trail shoes for wide feet. A new title and description that name that need is the first edit.

The tips post comes second. It has a position problem, so it needs better content, not a new title. The boot sizing page does fine, so it waits.

One change at a time, with a date

Change one thing per page, then stop. If you edit the title, the intro and the FAQ on the same day, you will never know which edit helped.

Also write down the date of the change, the page, and what you did. A plain sheet works. Without that date, the numbers you look at later have nothing to compare against.

Measure on a control day

Pick a control day about 14 days after the change. On that day, compare equal windows: the 14 days before the change against the 14 days after it. Leave the change day itself out.

Then compare the page with the whole site. Say the shoe guide went from 240 to 330 clicks, a rise of about 38%. If the site as a whole rose 5% over the same days, the page beat the trend by a wide margin. However, if the site rose 30%, the edit did little on its own.

Also check that Googlebot opened the page after your edit. If Google has not crawled it yet, the result says nothing about the change, so wait longer.

How Pagereckon Pro finds which pages to update first

Pagereckon Pro runs this exact method inside WordPress. It reads Search Console through a read-only connection, and the data stays on your own server.

  • Candidates: pages with many impressions and too few clicks, with the missed clicks per page and a CTR or position label.
  • Ideas: search terms that no page on your site covers yet.
  • Marks: you mark a page when you change it, and Pro sets a control day 14 days later by default.
  • Report: on that day it compares equal windows on both sides of the change, up to 28 days, next to the whole site. Then it says better, worse, no clear change, too little data or too early.

It calls a page better or worse only when its clicks moved at least 15% more than the site and by at least 3 clicks. In addition, Pro warns when Googlebot has not crawled the page since the change. It suggests and measures, but it never rewrites your content. See SEO testing and Search Console CTR for the details.

Which pages to update first: questions

How do I know which pages to update first?

Sort your Search Console pages by impressions, then count missed clicks: impressions times a typical CTR for the position, minus actual clicks. The pages with the most missed clicks are the ones to update first.

Why 28 days and not three months?

Rankings change. A 28-day window shows where a page stands now, while three months can hide a recent drop or rise.

Should I update pages first or write new posts?

Start with the pages that miss the most clicks, since they already have demand. Then use the search terms no page covers as ideas for new posts.

How long should I wait before I judge a change?

About two weeks is a common start, as long as Googlebot has crawled the page again. Then compare equal windows before and after, and check the trend of the whole site.

Are the typical CTR values exact?

No. They are rounded averages that help you rank pages against each other. Your real CTR also depends on the niche, brand searches and the features Google shows.

Sources and references

Free plugin, optional Pro

See your own AI traffic in ten minutes

Install the free plugin, point it at your access log and read today's humans, bots and AI visits. Then add Pro when you want Search Console and the before and after reports.