Independent Analytics vs Pagereckon: script counter or server log
Independent Analytics is a WordPress plugin that records each visit through a short script and the REST API, while Pagereckon reads the access log your server already writes. Both keep data in your own WordPress site, and neither sends it to an outside service.
So the real difference is the method. Below you will find a short table, the strengths of each plugin, and the cases where one fits better.
About Independent Analytics: A popular WordPress analytics plugin with a clean dashboard that records visits through a small script and the WordPress REST API. Visit their site
| Feature | Pagereckon | Independent Analytics |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free plugin; Pro from $69 a year | Free plugin; paid Pro version |
| How visits are counted | Server access log (or a PHP request log) | A script calls the WordPress REST API on each visit |
| Cookies | None | None, by the vendor's description |
| Bot handling | Known bots, scanners and disguised bots | Ignores bots that identify themselves |
| AI crawlers per page | Yes, split into training, AI search and live reads | Not a listed feature |
| AI referral visits | Yes, per assistant | AI platforms appear in the Referrers report |
| Campaigns (UTM) | Sources include utm_source | Pro: Campaigns report and builder |
| Ecommerce and forms | Affiliate link clicks only | Pro: WooCommerce and form tracking |
| Search Console | Pro | Not a listed feature |
What Independent Analytics does well
Independent Analytics has a polished dashboard that many site owners like on day one. It shows views, visitors, sessions, bounce rate, referrers, countries and devices. In addition, you get CSV and PDF export, saved reports and a dashboard widget.
The free plugin already covers a lot. For example, it can show view counts on posts, ignore chosen user roles and IP addresses, and delete old data on a schedule. It also has over 100,000 active installs and strong ratings on WordPress.org.
The Pro version adds more marketing tools. It brings a Campaigns report with a UTM builder, a real-time report, click tracking, user journeys, form tracking and ecommerce analytics for WooCommerce and other stores. Pagereckon does not try to match those.
How Pagereckon differs from Independent Analytics
Pagereckon starts from the log, not from a script. Every request your server answers leaves a line, so the count includes visits where a script never ran. Then the plugin decides, line by line, whether a human or a bot made the request.
Bots that hide
Independent Analytics skips bots that announce themselves, and its FAQ points to Cloudflare or Wordfence for disguised bots. Pagereckon handles those itself. It flags scanners by the paths they probe and disguised bots by how they behave. A real browser must also load a 42-byte beacon once per session before it counts as human.
AI crawlers next to AI visitors
Both plugins can show visitors who arrive from AI tools. However, Pagereckon also lists the AI crawlers that read each page, such as GPTBot or ClaudeBot, and groups them into training, AI search and live reads. Our AI referral traffic page shows how the two views fit together.
Google watch and fine-tuning
Pagereckon also logs Googlebot visits per page. With Pro, it reads Search Console, finds pages with many impressions and few clicks, and measures each edit with a control-day report. See SEO testing for that workflow.
Limits to weigh before leaving Independent Analytics
Pagereckon needs read access to your server access log. When a host hides it, the plugin falls back to a PHP request log. That fallback is less complete, because pages served from a page cache never reach PHP.
Also, Pagereckon has no form tracking, no user journeys and no store revenue reports. If those drive your decisions, the script-based approach will serve you better.
Pick Independent Analytics if
- You want a friendly dashboard with campaigns, forms and WooCommerce revenue in one place.
- Export to CSV or PDF and white-label reports matter for your clients.
- Your host gives you no access to the server log at all.
Pick Pagereckon if
- Counts should come from the server log, so a blocked script cannot hide a visit.
- You need disguised bots and scanners filtered without a separate firewall plugin.
- AI crawlers per page and Googlebot visits after an edit are part of your routine.
- Search Console candidates and before and after reports would help your editing.
Independent Analytics vs Pagereckon: questions
Does Independent Analytics use cookies?
The vendor says it does not use cookies for visitors and does not store personal data. Pagereckon also sets no visitor cookies and keeps no visitor IP addresses in its database.
Can Independent Analytics show AI traffic?
Its Referrers report recognizes AI platforms as sources. AI crawlers per page are not a listed feature, and that is where Pagereckon adds a view.
Which one is lighter on my server?
Independent Analytics writes each visit with one database query. Pagereckon instead reads the log in the background every 10 minutes, so page loads do no extra work beyond a tiny beacon.
Is Pagereckon a full Google Analytics replacement?
For pages, sources, countries and devices, yes. For events and audiences, no. Our Google Analytics alternative page explains the trade.